| Platinum | O.I.P |
| Gold | Waterstone Pizza |
| Silver | Marco's Pizza |
| Bronze | Isabella's Italian Trattoria |
| Top Pick | Graziano's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Jo Jo Pizza & Grill of Lynchburg |
| Top Pick | Ledo Pizza |
| Top Pick | Monte Carlo Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Rivermont Pizza |
| Top Pick | Vitale's Pizza Kitchen |