| Platinum | Woodruff Store Cafe & Pie Shop |
| Gold | Father's Cafe & Bakery |
| Silver | Ry's Pies ‘N Cobblers At The Lynchburg Community Market |
| Bronze | Cinn City |
| Top Pick | Chestnut Hill Bakery |
| Top Pick | Montana Plains Bakery |
| Top Pick | Mrs. Joys' |
| Top Pick | Sweet Fox |
| Top Pick | Sweet Indulgence Bakery |
| Top Pick | The Flour District |